Median sales price
$835,000Up from $779,500
Prices continued to climb.
Wantagh market report
Market numbers matter most when they help you decide what to do next.
The last 12 months
Here’s how the 12 months ending October 2026 compare with the year before.
Median sales price
$835,000Up from $779,500
Prices continued to climb.
Closed sales
203Down from 216
Fewer homes changed hands.
Median days on market
22 daysUp from 17.5 days
Homes took longer to sell.
Beyond the monthly numbers
These findings come from Wantagh existing-home sales during the 12 months ending October 2026.
34 of 203 homes—about 17%—sold in $750,000–$799,999.
Homes sold above asking
121 of 203 homes sold above asking. Among those homes, the average was approximately $54,399 over.
Time on the market
89% of existing homes that sold within 14 days closed above asking, compared with 7% after 60 days.
These are market patterns, not guarantees. Price range, school area, condition, competition and property-specific features all influence an individual result.
A closer local comparison
This compares existing-home sales by the high-school area reported in the MLS. Sample sizes differ, so use the results as local context—not a prediction for an individual home.
| Wantagh | General Douglas MacArthur | |
|---|---|---|
| Number of sales | 100 | 87 |
| Median sales price | $880,000 | $795,000 |
| Sold above asking | 62% | 57.5% |
| Median days on market | 20.5 days | 23 days |
The median-price spread between these groups was approximately $85,000. That difference describes the homes that sold; it does not measure the effect of a school area by itself.
The bigger picture
The October snapshot sits alongside the retained historical chart below.
Annual median sale price
The median increased by approximately $310,000 from 2019 to 2026 YTD.
Historical figures are based on available OneKey® MLS data. 2026 figures are year-to-date through September and are not completed-year totals. Historical FastStats values are retained pending the next official release.
Your situation matters too
Combine Wantagh's recent market data with your timing, plans and financial considerations for a personalized assessment.
Local real estate guidance
Whether you are buying, selling or doing both, share a few details and Matthew will connect you with a licensed real estate professional suited to your request.
Your information is reviewed, an appropriate local agent is selected, and that agent contacts you using your stated preference.
Source: OneKey MLS data through October 2026. Single-family homes only.
The rolling 12-month snapshot is calculated from the six supplied OneKey MLS closed-sale sheets. Current: November 1, 2025–October 31, 2026; comparison: November 1, 2024–October 31, 2025. Active inventory was counted on October 31, 2026. Seven questionable 2025 closing prices and one duplicate Merrick transaction were excluded. Market time is the median exported DaysOnMarket field, not cumulative days or an average. Above asking means closing price exceeded original list price; the average premium includes only those above-asking sales. Price bands use non-overlapping $50,000 intervals, including both endpoints, with all ties shown. Months of inventory divides available inventory by the average monthly pace of closed sales during the 12 months ending October 2026. The price-band insight covers 203 publicly marketed sales not marked as new construction. Above-asking and local comparisons use eligible records with the required fields. Private/MLS-only records and records marked as new construction were excluded from those findings; unmarked construction status was not inferred.
Historical annual figures are based on available OneKey MLS data. The 2026 figure is year-to-date through September and is not a completed-year comparison. Historical values have not been replaced by rolling 12-month statistics.
Market information is believed to be reliable but is not guaranteed and may contain errors or later revisions. It is provided for general informational purposes, not as an appraisal or promise of a particular result.